To Drink or Not To Drink: Coffee and Interviews

There have been two coffee related interview scenarios going around recently that I want to discuss. Oddly, I love one of them a lot, and the other seems stupid.

I shall start stupid (as is the typical case) Also note, the exact liquids don’t exactly matter, hot or cold, other than they are something to drink.

The iced coffee conundrum

Let’s set the stage. You get to an interview, and you have a drink with you when you arrive. In the scenario, it is an iced coffee and all the sweaty plastic cup that this entails. The supposition is that this is a bad idea.

This supposition is absolutely correct.

Note that there are probably reasons why you might need to bring a drink with you everywhere, and if necessary, it should be explained to the people interviewing you. (Still, a sweaty sugary coffee probably doesn’t fit that bill). A sealable bottle of water or whatever you need should suffice in that case.

The biggest thing to realize in any interview is that everything you do that cannot be helped is going to be put under a microscope. It doesn’t matter what that is. Your interview may be in a no-drinking room. They may want to show you around a computer room. Who knows?

The key is that you need to be at your most flexible, and the best version of yourself possible. Pretend you might meet the CEO of the organization and have lunch with them. Likely only if you are nearly that level, but would you take a drink into your current CEO’s office and set it down on their desk or floor?

So while you should never deprive yourself of a drink, meds, etc, making it seem the least possible amount of obnoxious is important. (This goes for pretty much all behavior, like even a sneeze. Sneezing is a necessity, but an exaggerated sneeze or uncovered sneeze can lose a job for you faster than not knowing some obvious detail).

The coffee offer

This scenario is one that I love, and would do it if I ever interview someone in person some day. I would offer them a drink, one that I myself will partake in. The story here is to see what they do with the drink and how they handle it.

The longer an interview, the more likely food and drink are going to be a part of it. “Would you like some coffee? Water, soda, snacks, etc.? Or even more interesting, “it is getting close to lunch, do you have time to get something with us?” All of these are interesting tools.

But the current question is simply that they offer you coffee. (Is it still current? These ideas sit in my notes for a while to be honest.) You like coffee, and others are drinking it, so do you accept it? Sure, unless you hate coffee (which I do unless it is mostly milk like a latte/cappuccino. Then maybe water or whatever else they offer.

Just realize that you are always being observed.

The original story is that the interviewers want to see what you do with the cup. Leave it on the table for someone else to take care of, or do you make sure that cup is taken care of. Even if they say “just leave it there” a simple “are you sure?” Is a good practice..

The bottom line

Everything you do in an interview is being watched constantly. So do your best to be your best. People want to see if you are going to be a good citizen. The whole concept of being a good fit for a team is important in terms of getting work done, but also that you won’t be a burden in others ways too.

Everything you do in an interview is extrapolated by your interviewer as being you at your best behavior. If that behavior isn’t good, it is multiplied in the interviewer’s mind.

I will confess whenever I think of a big sweaty coffee, my mind imagines someone with their feet up on the table. Not that I imagine any interviewee has ever done it, but just because those drinks are something I equate to being out by a pool or at a theme park.

Which is a huge problem with all of this. You have no idea what your interviewers are looking for or thinking when they see any of this. Some might see you strolling in with a 1/2 gallon of cold brew as a power move “This person has guts. Anyone willing to do that in an interview must need us less than we need them.

I just wouldn’t risk it…

Fediverse reactions

Leave a Reply